Question:
These questions were asked 2nd time May 18th. Now I am sending 3rd time
JazakAllah
Question sent May 1st but not answered
A boy proposed a girl. Both are students so parents decide to do nikah only. The boy secretly has sexual relationship with the girl without rukhsati. When girl asks for rukhsati and he refuses she argues. The boy divorces her giving the reason that she is stubborn and disobedient to elders. The boys mom admits that this was not a valid reason for divorce.Is there any punishment for this boy in the light of Islam?
Question sent April 28th but not answered
According to some school of thought, there is no existance of 3 talaaq in one sitting in the Quran. Therefore if 3 talaaq are given in one sitting it only counts as one. I have also read that many Islamic countries who follow shariah law also keep the same law. Is this true?
Answer:
In the name of Allah, Most Compassionate, Most Merciful,
As-salāmu ‘alaykum wa-rahmatullāhi wa-barakātuh.
We apologize for our belated response.
1) In principle, once the Nikah is performed, the woman becomes Halal for her husband. It is permissible for them to engage in sexual relations regardless of the Rukhsati taking place or not.
In the enquired situation, we understand that the husband should not have hastily issued a divorce. The matter should have been civilly discussed with both families as it is a sensitive matter considering that the both of them were students.
Nevertheless, if the husband uttered the words of divorce, the divorce will still occur regardless of his reasoning.
2) In principle, if a person gives his wife three divorces in one sitting, this will constitute three talaqs and talaq-e-mughalazah (a permanently irrevocable divorce) takes place.
You may refer to our detailed research on that at: http://www.askimam.org/public/question_detail/17287
